People ask whether a crypto asset “is a security or a commodity,” as if those were the two answers on a single form. In U.S. federal law they are questions under different statutes, asked for different purposes, sometimes about a transaction and sometimes about a market. An asset can raise one, the other, or both, depending on what someone is doing with it. This article is about those U.S. categories. It is not a description of European, UK, or Asian regimes, and it is not legal advice about any particular token.
What the securities statutes are for
The Securities Act of 1933 regulates the offer and sale of securities, unless an exemption applies. The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 regulates securities markets, brokers, exchanges, and ongoing disclosure. Neither statute was written with bitcoin in mind. Both apply when the thing being offered or traded is a security. The statutes then define “security” with a list, and the list includes an investment contract, which is where most crypto arguments happen.
The Supreme Court construed “investment contract” in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946). The Court looked at an arrangement in which buyers were offered units in a citrus grove together with a service contract. It held that an investment contract means an investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits to come from the efforts of others. The opinion uses the word “solely” for those efforts. Later cases have told courts to look at economic reality rather than at labels. In SEC v. Edwards, 540 U.S. 389 (2004), the Court applied Howey again and held that a promise of a fixed return can still be a profit for this purpose. The test is attached to a scheme or a transaction. It is not a sticker that a protocol prints on a coin.
That is why “is the token a security?” is often the wrong shape. A sale of tokens to the public, with a promoter’s promises about the work the promoter will do, is a different fact pattern from a later transfer of a token between two people who are not relying on that promoter. The first can be an investment-contract question. The second may not be the same question. Collapsing them into one permanent label is how commentary gets ahead of the cases. This article does not try to settle any individual enforcement action. The method is the point: identify the transaction, then apply the statute that governs that transaction.
What the commodity statute is for
The Commodity Exchange Act uses a broad definition of “commodity.” Section 1a(9), 7 U.S.C. § 1a(9), lists agricultural products and then reaches “all other goods and articles” and “all services, rights, and interests” in which contracts for future delivery are dealt in, or may be dealt in. The point of the definition is the CFTC’s authority over derivatives markets: futures, swaps, and the intermediaries in those markets. It is not a prize awarded to an asset for being decentralized.
Courts have treated virtual currency as capable of being a commodity under that statute. In CFTC v. McDonnell, 287 F. Supp. 3d 213 (E.D.N.Y. 2018), the district court held that virtual currencies are commodities and that the CFTC could police fraud in the spot market when the conduct falls within the Act. The CFTC has for years described bitcoin as a commodity in public enforcement and guidance. Chair Gensler’s 10 January 2024 statement on spot bitcoin exchange-traded products used the same framing for that one asset: the Commission’s action was “cabined to ETPs holding one non-security commodity, bitcoin,” and he wrote that it did not signal the Commission’s views on the status of other crypto assets under the securities laws.
Read that limitation literally. It is a statement about bitcoin in that order. It is not a holding that every other token, including ether, has been placed in a single federal category. Ether has been discussed by both agencies, in different contexts, over several years. A careful article does not promote those discussions into one nationwide classification. If a futures market exists on an asset, the commodity question is about that market and the CFTC’s jurisdiction over it. If a promoter is selling an expectation of profit based on the promoter’s efforts, the securities question is still sitting there, separately.
Why the questions can both be alive
A commodity can be the subject of a futures contract and also the subject of a securities offering if the offering is an investment contract. The categories are administered by different agencies because they police different relationships. The SEC’s retail-disclosure regime and the CFTC’s derivatives-market regime do not become the same regime when the underlying asset is a token. A bitcoin futures contract listed on a CFTC-regulated exchange is a derivatives question. A share of a bitcoin trust listed on a stock exchange is a securities question about the share, which is why the January 2024 order is an Exchange Act order even though the order calls bitcoin a commodity.
The practical test, when a headline picks one word, is to ask what conduct is being described. Is someone offering a scheme and asking for money? Look at Howey and the Securities Act. Is someone listing a future, a swap, or a leveraged retail contract? Look at the Commodity Exchange Act and whether that contract is being offered on a registered market. Is someone buying a bearer asset from a stranger with no promoter in the middle? Neither statute hands you a slogan. The facts of that sale still decide.
Other jurisdictions do not use this pair. A European regulation can cover an asset the U.S. discussion is still splitting, and a U.S. enforcement theory can have no counterpart abroad. Importing the word “security” or “commodity” into a foreign statute, or importing a foreign license into the Howey test, produces a sentence that is not checkable. Name the country, name the statute, and then ask the question that statute actually contains.
Howey was a grove, not a token
The 1946 facts are worth keeping because they show what kind of arrangement the Court was classifying. Buyers were offered rows of a citrus grove. The service company cultivated the trees and marketed the fruit. The buyers were not being asked to farm. They were being asked to put in money and receive the results of someone else’s work. The Court said form should be disregarded in favor of substance, and that the Securities Act reaches the countless schemes that fall within the ordinary concept of a security. A token white paper that promises a platform, a promoter, and a return is being analogized to that structure. The analogy can fit or fail. The grove does not decide the token. It decides which facts are relevant: who is doing the work the buyer is relying on, and whether the buyer was offered a profit from that work.
Edwards matters because it blocks a popular escape. The Court held that a scheme promising a fixed rate of return can still be an investment contract. “We called it interest” or “we called it a yield” is not a door out of Howey. Nor is “we called it a utility token.” The name on the website is the label the Court said to look through. The transaction terms are the record.
The commodity side has its own temptation, which is to treat “commodity” as a compliment meaning “not a security, and therefore unregulated.” McDonnell cuts the other way. The court accepted that a virtual currency can be a commodity and that the Commodity Exchange Act still reaches fraud in certain spot transactions, not only fraud in futures. A commodity is inside a statute. It is not outside the law. Bitcoin’s treatment as a commodity tells you which statute and which agency have been applied to bitcoin markets. It does not tell you that a different token’s fundraising round was a commodity trade. That round still has to be read under the securities laws if it has the shape Howey describes.
Sources
- SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946).
- SEC v. Edwards, 540 U.S. 389 (2004).
- 7 U.S.C. § 1a, Commodity Exchange Act definitions, including “commodity.”
- Chair Gary Gensler, 10 January 2024 statement, limiting that day’s action to bitcoin as a non-security commodity.
- CFTC v. McDonnell, No. 18-cv-361 (E.D.N.Y. 2018), the district court’s opinion on virtual currencies as commodities.




